Model/Monitor/Design Calibration Factors

ratios involving design values and measures of severity of modeled and monitored ozone concentration

Modeled measure of severity (MOS) is defined as the denominator and numerator of the rrf calculation for base and future case respectively (divided by number of days in the calculation).

Monitored measure of severity is defined in the corresponding fashion using monitored data.
designmodel>model/model/design/
monitorstatecountyvalueMOSMOSmonitordesignmonitor
390030002Ohio Allen 88.0 81.4not calc. 0.804 0.912 0.881
390071001Ohio Ashtabula 95.6 124.2not calc. 1.172 1.052 1.114
390170004Ohio Butler 89.6 96.2not calc. 0.913 1.052 0.867
390171004Ohio Butler 87.6 96.2not calc. 0.937 1.032 0.908
390250022Ohio Clermont 89.3 99.1not calc.-99.069 1.019 -1.000
390610006Ohio Hamilton 90.3 99.8not calc. 0.943 1.026 0.919
390610010Ohio Hamilton 85.6 99.8not calc. 1.004 1.127 0.891
390610040Ohio Hamilton 86.0 99.8not calc. 0.974 1.074 0.907
391650006Ohio Warren 90.6 99.5not calc. 0.959 1.017 0.942
390230001Ohio Clark 88.6 90.0not calc. 0.861 1.013 0.850
390230003Ohio Clark 85.3 93.9not calc. 0.952 1.064 0.895
390570006Ohio Greene 87.6 93.9not calc. 0.947 1.029 0.921
391090005Ohio Miami 87.0 90.0not calc. 0.904 0.994 0.909
391130019Ohio Montgomery 86.5# 93.9not calc. 0.941 1.050 0.896
391351001Ohio Preble 80.0 87.6not calc. 0.913 1.070 0.854
390271002Ohio Clinton 94.3 93.3not calc. 0.896 0.978 0.916
390350034Ohio Cuyahoga 78.3 111.0not calc. 1.179 1.240 0.950
390350064Ohio Cuyahoga 81.6 114.5not calc. 1.189 1.195 0.994
390355002Ohio Cuyahoga 88.0 111.0not calc. 1.072 1.117 0.960
390550004Ohio Geauga 99.0 101.9not calc. 0.866 0.989 0.876
390850003Ohio Lake 92.6 120.0not calc. 1.097 1.048 1.046
390853002Ohio Lake 83.0 120.0not calc. 1.285 1.168 1.100
391331001Ohio Portage 91.0 93.4not calc. 0.952 1.022 0.932
391030003Ohio Medina 87.0 97.1not calc. 1.031 1.052 0.980
391530020Ohio Summit 93.3 99.4not calc. 0.929 0.966 0.962
390410002Ohio Delaware 89.0 90.2not calc. 0.904 0.976 0.926
390490028Ohio Franklin 86.0# 89.2not calc. 0.889 0.991 0.897
390490029Ohio Franklin 93.0# 88.7not calc. 0.821 0.955 0.860
390490037Ohio Franklin 86.5# 89.2not calc.-89.207 1.007 -1.000
390490081Ohio Franklin 84.0 89.2not calc. 0.910 1.046 0.870
390830002Ohio Knox 87.0 88.5not calc. 0.911 0.989 0.920
390890005Ohio Licking 88.0 87.6not calc. 0.868 1.003 0.865
390970007Ohio Madison 88.6 93.4not calc. 0.942 0.998 0.944
390810016Ohio Jefferson 86.0# 90.4not calc. 0.948 1.024 0.925
390870006Ohio Lawrence 82.0 92.7not calc. 0.961 1.098 0.876
390870011Ohio Lawrence 76.6 92.7not calc. 1.071 1.166 0.918
390930017Ohio Lorain 87.0 114.5not calc. 1.114 1.113 1.001
390950024Ohio Lucas 83.3 85.8not calc. 0.913 1.072 0.852
390950027Ohio Lucas 82.0 84.5not calc. 0.943 1.013 0.931
390950034Ohio Lucas 90.0 117.9not calc. 1.194 1.094 1.092
390950081Ohio Lucas 88.6 85.8not calc. 0.875 1.008 0.869
391730003Ohio Wood 87.6 84.5not calc. 0.834 0.962 0.867
390990013Ohio Mahoning 87.0 92.5not calc. 0.929 1.035 0.898
391550011Ohio Trumbull 92.5# 94.8not calc.-94.756 0.975 -1.000
391550009Ohio Trumbull 88.0 94.8not calc. 0.964 1.036 0.931
391510016Ohio Stark 88.0 88.4not calc. 0.917 0.958 0.958
391510021Ohio Stark 86.3 84.8not calc.-84.776 0.955 -1.000
391511009Ohio Stark 88.3 88.4not calc. 0.919 0.976 0.941
391514005Ohio Stark 88.3 93.4not calc. 0.937 1.003 0.934
391670004Ohio Washington 85.6 92.9not calc. 0.934 1.043 0.895
170010006Illinois unknown 77* 77.2not calc. 0.908 0.972 0.934
170190004Illinois unknown 76* 83.7not calc. 0.985 1.058 0.931
170310001Illinois Cook 82* 94.2not calc. 0.985 1.108 0.889
170310032Illinois Cook 87* 94.2not calc. 0.924 1.048 0.882
170310042Illinois Cook 85.6 94.2not calc. 0.852 1.037 0.822
170310050Illinois Cook 74* 94.2not calc. 1.063 1.231 0.863
170310064Illinois Cook 76* 94.2not calc. 1.055 1.209 0.872
170310072Illinois Cook 80* 94.2not calc. 0.959 1.106 0.867
170311003Illinois Cook 82* 90.6not calc. 0.962 1.134 0.848
170311601Illinois Cook 74* 96.3not calc. 1.081 1.147 0.943
170314201Illinois Cook 83* 97.0not calc. 1.070 1.098 0.975
170317002Illinois Cook 83.6 90.6not calc. 0.944 1.071 0.881
170318003Illinois Cook 0.0 94.2not calc. 1.217 -1.000 -1.000
170436001Illinois unknown 73* 96.3not calc. 1.100 1.234 0.891
170491001Illinois unknown 75* 84.6not calc. 0.979 1.068 0.917
170650001Illinois unknown 79* 91.3not calc. 0.998 1.091 0.915
170831001Illinois unknown 89* 109.2not calc. 1.028 1.055 0.974
170890005Illinois unknown 79* 85.0not calc. 0.982 1.036 0.948
170971002Illinois Lake 82* 95.6not calc. 0.949 1.116 0.850
170971007Illinois Lake 84.6 95.6not calc. 0.865 1.081 0.800
170973001Illinois Lake 0.0 95.6not calc. 1.058 -1.000 -1.000
171110001Illinois unknown 84* 85.0not calc. 0.930 0.974 0.955
171150013Illinois unknown 75* 85.5not calc. 0.967 1.082 0.894
171170002Illinois unknown 78* 89.2not calc. 1.016 1.082 0.939
171190008Illinois unknown 88* 107.8not calc. 1.116 1.063 1.050
171191009Illinois unknown 83* 110.5not calc. 1.115 1.154 0.966
171192007Illinois unknown 82* 110.5not calc. 1.154 1.172 0.984
171193007Illinois unknown 81* 107.8not calc. 1.218 1.150 1.059
171430024Illinois unknown 72* 88.4not calc. 1.072 1.189 0.901
171431001Illinois unknown 80* 88.4not calc. 0.977 1.075 0.908
171570001Illinois unknown 79* 97.3not calc. 1.091 1.141 0.956
171630010Illinois unknown 83* 110.5not calc. 1.122 1.158 0.968
171670010Illinois unknown 76* 90.1not calc. 1.083 1.139 0.951
171971008Illinois unknown 79* 88.0not calc. 0.988 1.105 0.894
171971011Illinois unknown 79* 84.9not calc. 0.947 1.029 0.920
172010009Illinois unknown 77* 80.4not calc. 0.944 1.013 0.932
172012001Illinois unknown 74* 80.4not calc. 0.948 1.054 0.900
180030002Indiana unknown 88* 84.2not calc. 0.894 0.921 0.972
180030004Indiana unknown 85* 84.2not calc. 0.855 0.949 0.901
180110001Indiana Boone 90* 88.3not calc. 0.814 0.962 0.846
180190003Indiana Clark 92* 104.6not calc. 1.027 1.036 0.991
180431004Indiana unknown 86* 105.9not calc. 1.032 1.105 0.934
180510011Indiana unknown 73* 93.5not calc. 1.155 1.235 0.935
180550001Indiana unknown 88* 88.5not calc. 0.928 0.960 0.967
180571001Indiana Hamilton 96* 97.7not calc. 0.927 0.963 0.962
180590003Indiana Hancock 94* 95.1not calc. 0.913 0.980 0.931
180630004Indiana Hendricks 85* 91.2not calc. 0.887 1.026 0.865
180690002Indiana unknown 84* 84.3not calc. 0.931 0.941 0.990
180710001Indiana unknown 85* 94.0not calc. 1.015 1.055 0.963
180810002Indiana Johnson 86* 92.3not calc. 0.908 1.048 0.866
180890022Indiana Lake 84* 108.8not calc. 1.085 1.109 0.978
180890024Indiana Lake 81* 98.3not calc. 1.102 1.076 1.025
180892008Indiana Lake 90* 94.2not calc. 0.918 0.888 1.034
180910005Indiana La Porte 93* 107.5not calc. 0.966 1.066 0.907
180910010Indiana La Porte 87* 107.5not calc. 1.000 1.112 0.900
180950010Indiana Madison 95* 95.1not calc. 0.893 0.953 0.937
180970042Indiana Marion 81* 99.4not calc. 1.008 1.128 0.893
180970050Indiana Marion 92* 97.7not calc. 0.924 0.998 0.926
180970057Indiana Marion 85* 99.4not calc. 0.926 1.092 0.848
180970073Indiana Marion 89* 99.4not calc. 0.869 1.038 0.838
181090005Indiana Morgan 85* 91.2not calc. 0.927 1.020 0.909
181270020Indiana Porter 86* 108.8not calc. 1.053 1.109 0.949
181270024Indiana Porter 87* 108.8not calc. 1.018 1.099 0.926
181270026Indiana Porter 86* 98.3not calc. 0.940 1.090 0.862
181290003Indiana unknown 84* 100.5not calc. 1.000 1.098 0.910
181410010Indiana unknown 84* 99.0not calc. 1.014 1.059 0.958
181411007Indiana unknown 93* 99.0not calc. 0.900 0.995 0.904
181411008Indiana unknown 88* 99.0not calc. 0.964 1.069 0.902
181450001Indiana Shelby 94* 91.7not calc. 0.855 0.961 0.889
181630012Indiana unknown 83* 100.5not calc. 1.003 1.116 0.899
181630013Indiana unknown 77* 100.5not calc. 1.089 1.192 0.913
181670018Indiana unknown 76* 92.3not calc. 1.078 1.146 0.941
181730002Indiana unknown 85* 110.9not calc. 1.111 1.119 0.993
181730008Indiana unknown 81* 104.1not calc. 1.083 1.142 0.948
181730009Indiana unknown 81* 104.1not calc. 1.132 1.151 0.983
210150003Kentucky Boone 83.6 101.0not calc. 1.050 1.110 0.946
210190017Kentucky Boyd 86.0# 92.1not calc. 0.880 1.064 0.827
210370003Kentucky Campbell 90.6 99.8not calc. 0.915 1.015 0.901
210430500Kentucky Carter 77.0 83.5not calc. 0.921 1.057 0.871
210590005Kentucky unknown 75.3 107.6not calc. 1.172 1.259 0.931
210890007Kentucky unknown 81.3 92.7not calc. 1.041 1.107 0.941
210910012Kentucky unknown 81.6 105.4not calc. 1.110 1.145 0.970
210930006Kentucky unknown 78.3 89.9not calc. 1.015 1.113 0.912
211010014Kentucky unknown 79.3 110.9not calc. 1.199 1.208 0.993
211110027Kentucky unknown 79.6 104.6not calc. 1.156 1.189 0.972
211110051Kentucky unknown 82.6 105.1not calc. 1.059 1.135 0.933
211111021Kentucky unknown 79.3 104.6not calc. 1.166 1.205 0.967
211170007Kentucky Kenton 85.0 99.8not calc. 0.951 1.090 0.872
211390003Kentucky unknown 82.6 94.5not calc. 1.030 1.080 0.954
211451024Kentucky McCracken 79.0 93.0not calc. 1.052 1.127 0.933
211850004Kentucky Oldham 85.3 104.6not calc. 1.068 1.119 0.954
211950002Kentucky Pike 73.3 82.5not calc. 0.973 1.091 0.892
212090001Kentucky unknown 68.6 94.0not calc. 1.156 1.275 0.906
260050003Michigan unknown 97* 104.6not calc. 0.935 0.982 0.952
260190003Michigan unknown 88* 108.2not calc. 1.147 1.067 1.075
260210014Michigan unknown 91* 103.6not calc. 1.006 1.059 0.950
260270003Michigan unknown 93* 90.3not calc. 0.839 0.954 0.879
260370001Michigan unknown 86* 82.1not calc. 0.936 0.922 1.016
260490021Michigan unknown 88* 83.0not calc. 0.914 0.934 0.978
260492001Michigan unknown 90* 85.5not calc. 0.920 0.914 1.007
260630007Michigan unknown 87* 86.3not calc. 0.919 0.943 0.974
260650012Michigan unknown 85* 82.1not calc. 0.888 0.909 0.977
260770008Michigan unknown 86* 84.8not calc. 0.876 0.951 0.921
260810020Michigan unknown 85* 92.9not calc. 1.000 1.025 0.976
260810022Michigan unknown 88* 90.2not calc. 0.978 0.975 1.004
260910007Michigan Lenawee 87* 81.3not calc. 0.904 0.907 0.996
260990009Michigan Macomb 92.3 91.1not calc. 0.929 0.950 0.977
260991003Michigan Macomb 95* 91.1not calc. 0.945 0.900 1.050
261050007Michigan unknown 89* 111.6not calc. 1.158 1.093 1.059
261130001Michigan unknown 81* 74.8not calc. 0.947 0.923 1.025
261210039Michigan unknown 95* 122.9not calc. 1.184 1.076 1.101
261250001Michigan Oakland 91* 86.1not calc. 0.883 0.928 0.952
261390005Michigan unknown 89* 92.9not calc. 0.969 0.975 0.994
261470005Michigan St. Clair 90* 100.6not calc. 0.957 1.028 0.931
261610008Michigan Washtenaw 91* 88.4not calc. 0.946 0.904 1.046
261630001Michigan Wayne 80.3 86.1not calc. 0.928 1.033 0.898
261630016Michigan Wayne 84.0 86.1not calc. 0.913 0.957 0.954
261630019Michigan Wayne 91* 86.1not calc. 1.001 0.905 1.107
270031001Minnesota unknown 69.6 86.7not calc. 1.197 1.163 1.029
270750005Minnesota unknown 60.6 63.1not calc. 0.892 -1.000 -1.000
270953051Minnesota unknown 70.0 71.7not calc. 0.979 1.037 0.944
271370034Minnesota unknown 64.3 61.8not calc. 0.921 -1.000 -1.000
271390505Minnesota unknown 0.0 76.0not calc. 1.063 -1.000 -1.000
291831002Missouri unknown 90.0 107.8not calc. 1.047 1.043 1.004
291895001Missouri unknown 85.6 110.5not calc. 1.100 1.127 0.976
360130006New York unknown 93.0 106.0not calc. 1.019 1.016 1.003
360130011New York unknown 87.0 92.1not calc. 0.940 1.030 0.913
360290002New York unknown 95.6 92.0not calc. 0.847 0.939 0.902
360450002New York unknown 91.3 93.3not calc. 0.854 0.972 0.879
360631006New York unknown 91.6 105.3not calc. 1.045 1.030 1.015
420030008Pennsylvania Allegheny 92* 95.8not calc. 0.938 0.989 0.948
420030010Pennsylvania Allegheny 90.6 95.8not calc. 0.896 1.007 0.889
420030067Pennsylvania Allegheny 91* 97.0not calc. 0.962 1.000 0.962
420031005Pennsylvania Allegheny 92* 98.1not calc. 0.922 0.979 0.942
420050001Pennsylvania Armstrong 90.6 95.3not calc. 0.907 1.000 0.907
420070002Pennsylvania Beaver 91.3 92.8not calc. 0.879 0.899 0.978
420070005Pennsylvania Beaver 92* 92.8not calc. 0.870 0.961 0.905
420070014Pennsylvania Beaver 86* 92.8not calc. 0.942 1.063 0.886
420210011Pennsylvania unknown 87* 96.5not calc. 1.063 1.048 1.014
420334000Pennsylvania unknown 90* 94.2not calc. 0.969 0.997 0.972
420490003Pennsylvania Erie 89.0 108.8not calc. 1.071 1.058 1.012
420590002Pennsylvania unknown 85.0 94.8not calc. 0.946 1.067 0.886
420730015Pennsylvania unknown 80* 97.8not calc. 1.059 1.124 0.943
420850100Pennsylvania unknown 91.3 94.8not calc. 0.900 0.989 0.910
421250005Pennsylvania Washington 89* 97.0not calc. 0.977 1.017 0.960
421250200Pennsylvania Washington 88* 97.0not calc. 1.002 1.029 0.973
421255001Pennsylvania Washington 85.6 90.4not calc. 0.899 1.056 0.851
421290006Pennsylvania Westmoreland 84* 98.1not calc. 1.028 1.079 0.953
421290008Pennsylvania Westmoreland 91* 97.3not calc. 0.957 1.000 0.957
460990007South Dakota unknown 64.6 62.4not calc. 0.944 -1.000 -1.000
540110006West Virginia Cabell 85.6 92.1not calc. 0.904 1.048 0.863
540250003West Virginia unknown 78.6 78.1not calc. 0.913 0.966 0.945
540291004West Virginia Hancock 84.6 90.4not calc. 0.881 1.045 0.843
540390010West Virginia unknown 84.0 101.3not calc. 1.126 1.124 1.002
540610003West Virginia unknown 78.6 90.4not calc. 0.986 1.120 0.881
540690007West Virginia Ohio 86.0# 92.9not calc. 0.946 1.037 0.912
541071002West Virginia unknown 85.6 92.9not calc. 0.907 1.053 0.861
550090026Wisconsin Brown 80.3 77.1not calc. 0.894 0.922 0.969
550290004Wisconsin Door 91.0 89.2not calc. 0.898 0.922 0.974
550370001Wisconsin Florence 68.0 65.3not calc. 0.911 1.038 0.878
550390006Wisconsin unknown 77.3 77.9not calc. 0.911 0.967 0.942
550590002Wisconsin unknown 96.0# 95.6not calc. 0.834 0.932 0.895
550590019Wisconsin unknown 98.3 95.6not calc. 0.783 0.910 0.861
550590022Wisconsin unknown 90.5# 89.3not calc. 0.809 1.008 0.803
550610002Wisconsin Kewaunee 89.3 82.6not calc. 0.837 0.871 0.961
550710004Wisconsin Manitowoc 81.5# 79.1not calc. 0.919 0.914 1.005
550710007Wisconsin Manitowoc 87.0 83.2not calc. 0.946 0.917 1.032
550790026Wisconsin Milwaukee 80.3 82.0not calc. 0.873 0.952 0.916
550790041Wisconsin Milwaukee 83.0 82.0not calc. 0.900 0.922 0.977
550790044Wisconsin Milwaukee 70.0 82.0not calc. 1.042 1.120 0.930
550790085Wisconsin Milwaukee 91.0 82.0not calc. 0.817 0.856 0.954
550791025Wisconsin Milwaukee 91.0# 89.3not calc. 0.893 0.918 0.973
550870009Wisconsin Outagamie 75.3 69.7not calc. 0.872 0.948 0.920
550890008Wisconsin Ozaukee 88.6 85.0not calc. 0.858 0.878 0.977
550890009Wisconsin Ozaukee 93.0 85.0not calc. 0.872 0.870 1.002
551010017Wisconsin Racine 91.6 89.3not calc. 0.790 0.986 0.802
551170006Wisconsin Sheboygan 97.0 85.3not calc. 0.757 0.844 0.897
551170007Wisconsin Sheboygan 85.0# 85.3not calc. 0.929 0.963 0.965
551250001Wisconsin unknown 68.0 62.6not calc. 0.913 -1.000 -1.000
551270005Wisconsin Walworth 81.3 85.5not calc. 0.968 1.010 0.958
551310009Wisconsin unknown 80.3 77.3not calc. 0.858 0.923 0.930
551330017Wisconsin unknown 79.0 80.1not calc. 0.914 0.988 0.925
551390011Wisconsin unknown 80.0# 71.1not calc. 0.842 0.895 0.941

I think we have more machinery of government than is necessary, too many parasites living on the labor of the industrious.


-- Thomas Jefferson